Illegittimo escludere

Unlawful to exclude a bidder for suing the contracting authority

Unlawful to exclude a bidder for suing the contracting authority

Illegittimo escludere

The Regional Administrative Court of Puglia, Lecce division, confirms the principle that exclusion grounds must be strictly limited by law

The case

In 2024, a municipality in the Province of Lecce launched a negotiated procedure for the award of cemetery services for the three-year period 2025–2027.

After receiving expressions of interest from seven companies, the municipality invited them to take part in the procedure by means of a Request for Offer through the MePA platform, with the contract to be awarded on the basis of the lowest price.

However, the award was subsequently annulled by the municipality under its self-review powers due to legality issues.

The successful bidder challenged the annulment and, while the proceedings were pending, the municipality launched a new tender procedure, introducing into the tender rules an exclusion clause targeting economic operators involved in litigation with the authority.

The Regional Administrative Court of Puglia, Lecce division, upheld the appeal with judgment no. 1256/2025 for the reasons set out below.

 

The decision

The exclusion clause included in the tender documentation, under which operators involved in administrative, tax or civil litigation with the municipality were not allowed to participate, was found to be inconsistent with the general principles of competition and broad participation in public tenders. It was also in direct conflict with the economic operator’s right to take legal action, as protected under Articles 24 and 113 of the Italian Constitution.

This principle is further reinforced by the Remedies Directive 2007/66/EC, the 2014 Public Procurement Directives and the corresponding implementing provisions under Legislative Decree no. 36/2023.

In public procurement, the ruling therefore confirms the principle that exclusion grounds must be strictly limited to those provided for by law. In particular, it confirms the unlawfulness of clauses that prevent economic operators from participating in tender procedures solely because of pending litigation with the contracting authority.

 

For further information:

- Regional Administrative Court of Puglia, Lecce division, judgment no. 1256/2025.

News


ance brescia 2026

Housing challenges and risk management: Verlingue at the ANCE Brescia 2026 Assembly

Housing challenges and risk management: Verlingue at the ANCE Brescia 2026 Assembly

ance brescia 2026

Housing affordability, innovation and risk management at the centre of the discussion between businesses and institutions

Access to housing has become an economic, social and industrial challenge. A topic that increasingly involves sustainability, investment, governance and innovation. Against this backdrop, Verlingue took part as Gold Sponsor of the ANCE Brescia 2026 Assembly, focused on the theme “Living. Housing as a social asset and infrastructure”.

 

Hosted at Eseb, the Assembly brought together institutions, companies and construction industry stakeholders to discuss the housing crisis and the need for long-term structural policies. In his opening speech, ANCE Brescia President Massimo Angelo Deldossi described housing as “a national systemic issue”, highlighting the strategic importance of cooperation between the public and private sectors. Economist Carlo Cottarelli also addressed the audience, stressing how rising property costs and growing barriers to home access require sustainable solutions and more effective governance models.

 

This evolving landscape is also reshaping the role of construction companies, which are now required to manage increasing operational, environmental and regulatory complexity. As a result, risk management is becoming a key strategic factor throughout the entire project lifecycle.

 

Verlingue supports construction businesses with dedicated insurance and risk management solutions, including:

- Third-party and employers’ liability insurance
- Contractors’ All Risks (CAR) and Post-Completion Decennial Liability cover
- All Risks cover for site equipment and machinery
- Surety bonds and guarantees
- Environmental liability insurance
- Business travel insurance solutions
- Fleet insurance programmes
Digital transformation, sustainability and changing housing needs are redefining the construction sector. In this context, risk management plays a central role in supporting businesses and local communities in building more resilient and sustainable development models.

News


Ente pubblico non qualificato

Public procurement: non-qualified authorities must also delegate market surveys

Public procurement: non-qualified authorities must also delegate market surveys

Ente pubblico non qualificato

Non-qualified public authority: market surveys must also be delegated to the central purchasing body

Contracting authorities may purchase goods and services only within the limits of their qualification level. This qualification is obtained through ANAC’s recognition of the requirements set out in Annex II.4, such as the presence of an internal office or department dedicated to procurement procedures, the availability of digital procurement platforms, and other relevant criteria.

 

As a result, where a contracting authority does not hold the required qualification, it must rely, for above-threshold procedures, on central purchasing bodies or other qualified entities included in the ANAC register.

 

The purpose of the new qualification system, as outlined in Articles 62 and 63 of the Public Contracts Code, is to ensure greater efficiency, professionalisation and rationalisation in public procurement.

The Italian Ministry of Infrastructure and Transport has recently addressed an interpretative issue: where a procedure is entrusted by a non-qualified authority to a central purchasing body, can the market survey be published and carried out by the non-qualified authority itself?

 

The question fits within the framework developed by administrative case law, which qualifies expressions of interest as a pre-tender phase with a purely exploratory purpose.

 

With opinion no. 4184 of 21 April 2026, the Ministry provided a clear answer: in the absence of the required qualification, the entire procedure, from the market survey through to the award, must be managed exclusively by the qualified entity.

 

It follows that no fragmentation of the procedure is permitted, as all stages, including preliminary phases, require the involvement of qualified entities.

 

For further information:

· Opinion no. 4184 of 21 April 2026 – Italian Ministry of Infrastructure and Transport;
· Articles 62 and 63, Annex II.4, Legislative Decree no. 36/2023

News


Enactus 2026

Verlingue supports Enactus Italy and the National Competition 2026

Verlingue supports Enactus Italy and the National Competition 2026

Enactus 2026

Supporting students and socially impactful entrepreneurial projects to foster skills and innovation

Verlingue is a Corporate Partner of Enactus Italia, an organisation that promotes entrepreneurial projects developed by university students with a strong social and environmental impact. Through the involvement of companies, partners and universities, Enactus Italy works to nurture a new generation of socially conscious leaders capable of turning innovative ideas into practical solutions for communities and local areas.

 

Partners within the network play a key role in supporting the organisation’s mission and in developing initiatives focused on sustainability, social inclusion, youth entrepreneurship and social impact innovation. In this context, Verlingue took part in the Enactus Italia National Competition 2026, held on 19 and 20 May 2026 in Reggio Emilia at the Centro Internazionale Loris Malaguzzi.

 

“Verlingue has been a partner of Enactus for three years now, and we are truly proud of this,” said Rossella Carapezzi, Head of Communications and Quality at Verlingue. “Every year, we see young people turning ideas into tangible change. We believe in them – in their energy, their creativity and their ability to make a difference. We care deeply about learning and growth. That is why our parent company established the Adelaide University Academy, to help people develop their skills and realise their potential.”

 

The event provided an opportunity for students, companies and partners to come together and share projects and ideas aimed at delivering concrete responses to future challenges.

For Verlingue, supporting initiatives such as Enactus Italy means contributing to the development of models based on responsibility, innovation and sustainable growth, while encouraging dialogue between businesses and younger generations.

News


festa di primavera 2026

Verlingue celebrates the 2026 Spring Celebration

Verlingue celebrates the 2026 Spring Celebration

festa di primavera 2026

A convivial evening at the Arzaga Golf Club to get together outside the everyday work environment

On Friday 15 May 2026, Verlingue Spa held its Spring Party, an event dedicated to the company’s staff and designed to allow everyone to share an evening in an informal and convivial setting.

The event took place at the Arzaga Golf Club, where colleagues from Verlingue’s various offices had the opportunity to meet outside the workplace, dine together and enjoy an evening accompanied by music. It was a chance to get together and share experiences, helping to strengthen internal relationships and a sense of belonging to the company.

For Verlingue, growth also depends on the quality of relationships between people: occasions such as this help to strengthen team spirit and highlight the human side of the organisation.

News


Verlingue al fianco di Gas Sales Bluenergy Volley Piacenza

Verlingue alongside Gas Sales Bluenergy Volley Piacenza

Verlingue alongside Gas Sales Bluenergy Volley Piacenza

Verlingue al fianco di Gas Sales Bluenergy Volley Piacenza

Verlingue supports Gas Sales Bluenergy Volley Piacenza, recent winners of the 2026 CEV Volleyball Cup

Gas Sales Bluenergy Volley Piacenza secured the first CEV Volleyball Cup in the club’s history after defeating SVG Lüneburg 3-0 in the second leg of the final in front of a sold-out PalabancaSport arena. The victory marks one of the most significant achievements for the Piacenza-based side in recent years and confirms the club’s growing role within the SuperLega Credem Banca, the top tier of Italian men’s volleyball.

 

Verlingue’s support is part of this journey, reaffirming its role as a supporter of the Piacenza club. A partnership built around shared values such as vision, growth, team spirit and the ability to face challenges with determination.

 

The success of the biancorossi is the result of a long-term path shaped by ambition, planning and a strong collective identity. These are principles that closely reflect Verlingue’s own corporate culture, as the company works every day alongside businesses and organisations in risk management and the development of long-term strategies.

 

Because, just as in the strongest organisations, the greatest achievements in sport are built on mutual trust, preparation and a shared vision.

News


Verlingue alla WBN Global Conference 2026 di Philadelphia

Verlingue at the WBN Global Conference 2026 in Philadelphia

Verlingue at the WBN Global Conference 2026 in Philadelphia

Verlingue alla WBN Global Conference 2026 di Philadelphia

International brokers meet in Philadelphia to discuss risk management and multi-country clients

The WBN Global Conference, one of the most significant events for the international insurance broking community, took place in Philadelphia from 29 April to 2 May 2026. The conference brought together professionals and partners from multiple markets, with the aim of strengthening global coordination and addressing the operational challenges of managing risk on an international scale.

 

Verlingue Italy’s participation forms part of a broader strategy to consolidate the Group’s position within the Worldwide Broker Network, with an increasing focus on multinational programmes and the integrated management of clients operating across multiple jurisdictions. The Italian delegation was represented by David Lee Rodriguez and Massimiliano Aloi.

 

Throughout the conference, discussions focused on key operational topics that are becoming increasingly central to the industry, including:

- the management of multinational insurance programmes;

- cross-border coordination and alignment with local regulatory frameworks;

- the evolving role of the broker as a central point of coordination between global client needs and local expertise.

 

We are delighted to take part in the WBN Conference in Philadelphia,” said Rodriguez, “a highly relevant international event that provides a valuable opportunity for dialogue, professional development and the creation of new business relationships. Being present at an event of this calibre confirms Verlingue Spa’s commitment to strengthening its presence in global markets and to continuing to deliver increasingly innovative and effective insurance solutions to its clients”.

 

In this context, Verlingue’s participation represented a strategic opportunity to reinforce relationships with international partners and to foster new avenues for collaboration.

News


affidamenti diretti

Direct awards following a market consultation: failure to invite must be justified

Direct awards following a market consultation: failure to invite must be justified

affidamenti diretti

The rules governing direct awards remain a particularly sensitive area for public authorities, especially where they are preceded by market consultations or expressions of interest.

A recent ruling by the Regional Administrative Court (TAR) of Calabria (Judgment No. 74/2026) clarifies the limits of administrative discretion in simplified procurement procedures.

 

The case

On 9 September 2025, a municipality in Calabria published a prior market consultation notice, as a preliminary step to launching a negotiated procedure (Article 50(b) of Legislative Decree No. 36/2023), for the award of a school catering service covering nursery, primary and lower secondary schools.

Four economic operators responded to the notice. However, one of them, without any explanation, was not subsequently invited to submit a tender.

The excluded operator challenged the award decision, and the claim was upheld on the following grounds.

 

Grounds for the decision

Article 50, read in conjunction with Annex I.1 of Legislative Decree No. 36/2023, provides that in the case of a direct award (i.e. awarding a contract without a formal tender procedure), the contracting authority retains discretion in selecting the contractor, even where several economic operators have been consulted in advance.

However, this discretion is not unfettered. It must comply with the general principles set out in Law No. 241/1990, including transparency, publicity, and—crucially—the obligation to state reasons for administrative decisions, a principle also rooted in constitutional law.

It follows that a direct award which fails to explain why an operator, despite having expressed interest, was not invited to submit a bid is unlawful, as it breaches the duty to provide reasons established under Law No. 241/1990.

 

For further details:

- TAR Calabria, Judgment No. 74/2026;

- Article 50 and Annex I.1 of Legislative Decree No. 36/2023;

- Articles 1 et seq., Law No. 241/1990.

News


Il “diritto di accesso difensivo automatico”: procedura d’infrazione contro l’Italia

“Automatic defensive access rights”: infringement proceedings against Italy

“Automatic defensive access rights”: infringement proceedings against Italy

Il “diritto di accesso difensivo automatico”: procedura d’infrazione contro l’Italia

The new Public Procurement Code has had a significant impact on access to documents in public tenders, seeking to strike a balance between two competing interests:

- full transparency of documents for economic operators;
- protection of sensitive technical and commercial information.

 

Article 35 of Legislative Decree No. 36/2023 provides that contracting authorities must ensure digital access to the full set of tender documents, including bidders’ technical offers (paragraphs 2 and 3). However, technical proposals may be withheld where they qualify as technical or commercial secrets, provided this is duly justified by the bidder (paragraph 4).

Conversely, paragraph 5 allows access to such confidential information where it is strictly necessary for the purposes of legal defence in relation to the procurement procedure (the so-called “automatic defensive access right”).

 

The European Commission’s position

The European Commission has launched infringement proceedings against Italy, arguing that granting automatic precedence to defensive access conflicts with Article 21 of Directive 2014/24/EU. This provision rules out national frameworks that allow unconditional access to technical or commercial secrets solely to ensure judicial protection (Order of 10 June 2025, Case C-686/2024, Court of Justice of the European Union).

Accordingly, domestic legislation cannot establish an automatic priority for the effectiveness of judicial protection. Instead, it must ensure a proportionate balancing of the interests involved, failing which it risks breaching both the principle of proportionality and the effective protection of confidential information.

 

Italian case law aligns

More recently, the Council of State, in judgment No. 10036/2025, clarified that defensive access to confidential information does not automatically override confidentiality concerns. Even where a request is made for defence purposes, public authorities are required to balance the right to judicial protection against the need to safeguard technical and commercial secrets.

 

For further details:

- Council of State, Judgment No. 10036/2025;

- Article 35, Legislative Decree No. 36/2023;

- Article 21 of Directive 2014/24/EU;

- Order of 10 June 2025, Case C-686/2024, Court of Justice of the European Union.

News


Mandatory insurance for administrative liability: entry into force postponed to 1 January 2027

Mandatory insurance for administrative liability: entry into force postponed to 1 January 2027

The requirement to take out an insurance policy covering financial losses caused to the public administration through gross negligence, introduced by Law No. 1/2026, will no longer come into effect during 2026.

An amendment to the so-called Milleproroghe Decree has pushed the implementation date back to 1 January 2027, giving public bodies an additional year to align with the new framework and address the many outstanding uncertainties.

At the heart of the issue remains the fact that the cost is to be borne entirely by the individual employee. This stems from the prohibition set out in Law No. 244/2007, which prevents public entities from insuring their officials against risks arising from the performance of their institutional duties, including liability for damage caused to the State.

 

What will happen in 2026?

With the postponement, the Government intends to carry out a comprehensive review of the framework, aiming to make the insurance requirement more sustainable while preserving the core objective of the reform: safeguarding public finances and ensuring responsible, transparent management of public resources.

As a result, 2026 will serve as a transitional year. Public administrations will be able to assess the impact of the reform, revise internal procedures, update delegated responsibilities, and work towards a system that—by 2027—can be implemented in a clearer, more coherent way that properly reflects the complexity of administrative action.

The new deadline also creates an opportunity to shape a more balanced regulatory framework, capable of combining legal certainty, economic sustainability, and the operational continuity of public administration.

 

For further details:
Decree-Law No. 200 of 31 December 2025, converted into Law No. 26/2026;
Law No. 244/2007.

News